BALANCE OF PAYMENT
Balance of Payments- Worksheet
- Distinguish between an import and an export
- Visible and invisible trade
- State whether the following are
i)
an export or an import for Hong
Kong
ii)
visible trade or invisible
trade
Transaction
|
Current/Capital/Financial
|
Credit/debit
|
A US company buying shares on the HK
stock market
|
|
|
HK citizen sending wages earned in UK
back to HK
|
|
|
A HK company selling prawns direct to
France
|
|
|
An Italian firm investing in a chain of
restaurants
|
|
|
HK company paying
dividends to US shareholder
|
|
|
4.
In which part of the HK Balance of Payments account would the
following transactions be recorded & state if they credit or debit
items
Transaction
|
Current/Capital/Financial
|
Credit/debit
|
A US company buying shares on the HK
stock market
|
|
|
HK citizen sending wages earned in UK
back to HK
|
|
|
A HK company selling prawns direct to
France
|
|
|
An Italian firm investing in a chain of
restaurants
|
|
|
HK company paying
dividends to US shareholder
|
|
|
5. The fictitious figures below refer to the HK’s balance of
payments for 2007, 08, 09 and 2010 Calculate for each year
a)
Balance on trade in goods
b)
Balance on trade in services
c)
The balance of trade
d) The
current account balance
Year
|
Goods exported
|
Goods imported
|
Services exported
|
Services imported
|
Net Income Flows
|
Net current transfers
|
2007
|
42,345
|
57,600
|
654,000
|
124,000
|
-12,500
|
-34,000
|
2008
|
123,000
|
245,786
|
12,789
|
9,876
|
123,765
|
47,987
|
2009
|
56,363
|
66,666
|
46,879
|
38,945
|
100,000
|
-99,999
|
2010
|
853,970
|
900,000
|
345,876
|
200,000
|
0
|
34,987
|
Factors which cause a current account Deficit in
the balance of Payments
Fixed
Exchange Rate
If the currency is
overvalued, imports will be cheaper and therefore there will be a higher Q of
imports. Exports will become uncompetitive and therefore there will be a fall
in the Quantity of exports.
Economic
Growth
If there is an
increase in AD and National Income increases, people will have more disposable
income to consume goods. If domestic producers can not meet the domestic AD,
consumers will have to imports goods from abroad. Therefore if there is fast
economic growth there tends to be a big increase in imports.
Decline
in Competitiveness.
IN the UK there has
been a decline in the exporting manufacturing sector, because it has struggled
to compete with developing countries in the far east. This has led to a
persistent deficit in the balance of trade.
Higher
inflation
This makes exports
less competitive and imports more competitive. However this factor may be
offset by a decline in the value of sterling.
Recession
in other countries.
If the UK’s
main trading partners experience negative economic growth then they will buy
less of our exports, worsening the current account.
Borrowing
money
If countries are
borrowing money to invest e.g third world countries
Deterioration
in the current account
This means that the value of exports has increased at a slower rate than the
value of imports. Therefore there could have been an increase in the deficit or
the surplus could have changed into a deficit.
Current Account Deficit
If there is a
current account deficit, then imports tend to exceed exports, this means that
the supply of the currency has risen as people have bought fewer products in
that country’s currency. This then causes a downward pressure on the exchange
rate and the relative value of the currency to fall, depreciation.
Implications of a persistent current account deficit
·
Exchange rates: the currency should automatically depreciate, which will
then help to rectify the deficit as exports become cheaper relative to imports.
·
Interest rates: the central
bank may decide to increase these in order to encourage foreign direct
investment, however, this may reduce domestic investment and consumption as
there is a greater incentive to save than spend which could lead to lower
levels of growth.
·
Indebtedness: if the country
is having to borrow in order to finance the current account deficit then they
may accumulate so much debt that they are unable to pay it back and so default.
This undermines confidence in the economy, so they may be unable to get any
future loans.
·
International credit ratings: a persistent
current account deficit may cause the international credit rating agencies to
lower their rating which may lead to even lower expectations about the
economy’s future.
·
Demand management: in order to rebalance the account deficit they make take
measure to reduce demand which can be very painful for the economy as a
whole.
Current Account Surplus
If there is a current
account surplus, then exports tend to exceed imports, this means that the
demand for the currency has risen as people have bought products in that
country’s currency. This then causes an upward pressure on the exchange rate
and the relative value of the currency to rise, appreciation.
Implications of a persistent current account surplus
·
Appreciation: as exports increase, the
demand for the currency increases and therefore the value of the currency
increases.
·
Reduced
export competitiveness: as the currency appreciates, in a floating
exchange rate, exports become comparatively more expensive so demand for
exports fall.
·
Lower
domestic consumption and investment: as the currency
appreciates, imports will become more affordable compared to domestic products
so consumption of domestic products falls. The appreciation can also deter
foreign investment from abroad as it becomes more expensive.
Is a Current Account Deficit a bad Thing?
Why a Current account is considered
harmful to the economy
1.
A current
account deficit is financed through borrowing or foreign investment. So the
country’s debt will increase.
2.
Borrowing
is unsustainable in the long term and countries will be burdened with high
interest payments. E.g Russia was unable to pay its foreign debt back in 1998.
Other developing countries have experience similar repayment problems Brazil,
African. (3rd World debt)
3.
Foreigners
have an increasing claim on UK assets, which they could desire to be returned
at any time. It means FDI will decrease. E.g. a severe financial crisis in
Japan may cause them to repatriate their investments
4.
Export
sector may be better at creating jobs. So, the employment opportunity in
domestic sector will decrease.
5.
A Balance
of Payments deficit may cause a loss of confidence in the economy.
However a current account deficit
is not necessarily harmful
1.
Current
Account deficit could be used to finance investment.
E.g. US ran a Current account deficit for a long time as it
borrowed to invest in its economy. This enabled higher growth and so it was
able to pay its debts back and countries had confidence in lending the US
money.
2.
Japanese
investment has been good for UK economy not only did the economy benefit from
increased investment but the Japanese firms also helped bring new working
practices in which increased labour productivity.
3.
With a
floating exchange rate a large current account deficit should cause a
devaluation which will help reduce the level of the deficit
It depend on the size of the budget deficit as a
% of GDP, for example the US trade deficit has nearly reached 5% of GDP (02/03)
at this level it is concerning economists
Methods to resolve a
current account deficit
Expenditure
switching policies:
This policies aims at
encouraging people to switch their spending on imports to domestic goods. These
may include:
· Devaluing the exchange rate,
· Tariffs
· Quota
· Embargo &
· Polices to reduce inflation.
The aim is to reduce the
demand and supply of imports, rather than reducing overall consumption.
Expenditure
reducing policies:
These policies aim to
reduce the real spending of consumers. Such policies include fiscal and
monetary polices.
· Contractionary Fiscal Policy &
· Contractionary Monetary Policy
For instance, the
government may increase taxes and reduce spending, whilst the central bank may
increase interest rates to incentivise saving.
Supply-side
policies:
Policies may be needed in
order to improve the country’s productivity in order to improve its exports
competitiveness in the international markets. These policies including lowering
production costs by reducing the minimum wage, trade union power, business taxes
and implementing deregulation.